by Dana Blankenhorn
Volume X, No. XXXI

This Week's Clue: A New Political Thesis

Home | Dana's Bio | Clued-In Archive | Newsletter '06 Archive | | Subscribe!
This Week's Clue: A New Political Thesis
SSP (Shameless Self Promotion)
Best of the Week
ZDNet Open Source
Clued-in, Clueless

Dana Recommends The Blankenhorn Effect offers a powerful, positive message for our time. Once you understand how Moore's Law impacts every part of your life, how powerful it is, and how irresistible a force it truly is, you will have the power to predict the future and know how to change it. Buy it today, and make 2006 a better year for yourself, your business, and your family.


For the Week of July 31, 2006

Most politics is transactional.

But once in a generation, a Crisis emerges requiring a Transformation. (For a review of terms to be used here, click here.)

The Crisis cannot be answered by either the existing Political Thesis, or its Anti-Thesis. The Myths and Values of the past lack the vocabulary to address the new Crisis.

So a new Thesis is needed, a belief structure that will address the Crisis, and which will be held, or opposed, until the old generation dies or a new Crisis emerges.

This has happened throughout America's history, at regular (and lengthening) intervals because we live longer and age more slowly:

In 2004, Democrats deliberately walked into this Thesis, nominating a candidate of the Anti-Thesis, John Kerry against GW Bush. Bush had already proven to be a leader of Excess, following his Thesis past its logical conclusion, yet the knees jerked, because we age so slowly. We still remembered the old battles, and responded to the old war cries.

But now a new Crisis has emerged. It can't be answered by the current Thesis. It can't be answered by the Anti-Thesis, best represented by Clinton's Third Way.

The new inspiration exists today, right in front of you. Like the old Palmolive ad says, you're soaking in it.

It's the Internet.

The medium you're using right now carries with it powerful Myths, and Values, on which a new future can be based. We see them emerge whenever issues of importance to the Internet emerge. When the Web was threatened with campaign finance regulation, left and right united. In the net neutrality fight, left and right are united.

What are these Values?

  • Openness - you can reach any site, and use the software you choose on the Internet.
  • Transparency - We are what we are, and secrecy is an enemy of progress.
  • Consensus - Progress starts with agreement.

Notice that these are optimistic values, liberating values. They're the values of 1776, and of 1860, and of 1932. A generation moves toward pessimism, and the next must move it the other way.

What story or Myth can we tell that puts these values into action and shows us how solutions can happen?

The story of the Internet itself holds the answer. The concept of the Web came from practically nowhere, a single scientist working at CERN in Switzerland. The Web itself is transparent, easy to navigate, everything just a few clicks away. And the standards themselves change through consensus, through broad agreements among companies, among people, among countries.

This is reflected best in the Open Source movement. Open Source encompasses a wide array of actors, from leftist idealists such as Richard Stallman to hard-edged capitalists like Jonathan Schwartz, CEO of Sun Microsystems. A wide variety of business models comfortably coexist. Progress is achieved through consensus. The more transparent a project, the more open to the community, the faster it can make change happen.

Google. Wikipedia. Open Office. A new world of software and services have been created. It's the greatest expansion in "the commons" we've seen in generations. Click away. I have friends in India, in South Africa, in Japan and Germany and Pakistan and Australia, in England and in dozens of other countries, and while we disagree about a lot there's consensus here on the Internet's Values, and on the Open Source Myth.

Here is the source, the wellspring, the new Political Thesis we've been looking for. Right under our noses.

What can we do with it? We can organize, we can learn, we can teach, we can listen to one another, we can find agreements. We do it every day. We do it at work, we do it from school, we do it from our homes, we do it in our underwear, and if we want we can even do it in the road.

But what does this teach us? What is Open Source Politics pointing us to?

  • The wealth of nations is human capital. Our skills, our knowledge, our creativity are what make wealth.
  • Networks are how we get this wealth to market. They are our ports, our highways, our railroads.
  • Institutions should try and mirror the Internet's Values of transparency, openness and consensus.

OK. But what about the problems that face us now?

Wars over oil and other resources are not worth the trouble. The solution to our energy and environmental problems is the same. Politicians should start with what they agree on, and work to broaden that, rather than starting with disagreements and hammering each other over the head with them.

A simple manifesto, yes. But a practical one. The work of implementing this will take a generation, but that's the idea.

Oh, and this is not just an American idea. This is a worldwide phenomenon. The nations growing fastest - China, India, Brazil - they are growing fastest in terms of the Internet and of open source. The ideals I'm talking about are held in common by thinkers of many, many nations, once they look up from their local squabbles. And those nations which aren't embracing these values? Those are the nations that are failing.

And who might be the first Open Source President?

Well, Nixon lost narrowly, in a disputed election, and even wrote his own political obituary. But that's a detail we can thresh out in time. Lincoln lost two years before his election.

And what makes me so smart? How am I qualified to bullshit on such vital topics? I'm a journalist, it's my job. I've also spent 23 years covering this medium, full-time. My first business card read "Have Modem, Will Travel."

Besides, you just finished reading this. Remember, ideas can come from anywhere.


Shameless Self-Promotion

I have made a big decision. I have moved my main blog, formerly called Mooreslore, to under the name Dana Blankenhorn. (Hey, that's MY name.) The blog is written in Typepad and is also available at

I'm continuing to produce a special blog on Open Sourcefor ZDNet. I am pleased to say it has grown into a real money-maker. I work as a freelance writer in Atlanta, and am on the development team for Voic.Us, which aims to become a political "super-site" and offer mobile marketing services. Please visit that blog as well.

You are encouraged to forward this newsletter widely. And if you have trouble subscribing let me know. Remember: it's journalism that keeps the Clues coming...


Best of the Week

The 1966 Game: Who's Sam Walton Now?

It could be anyone.

Why Make Half the Market Hate You?

I have never, ever seen a company so determined to piss off half the country.

Best Bike Race Ever

Even Lance never did what I saw Floyd Landis do today.

The Perfect Copy Isn't

The DMCA was passed in 1998 based on a very, very big lie.

Why the Stem Cell Veto Doesn't Matter

Science doesn't care about Bush. And it doesn't care about America all that much, either.

Idealism in the Value of this Medium

The choices in the now are all bad. And fact is Americans -- ordinary Americans -- can have no impact on those choices.

$50 Billion Down Bell Rathole

That is apparently what the Bells have squandered in Universal Service Fund payments over the last two decades.

Can Education Save U.S. Technology?

This, I'm proud to say, is something we can change, and are changing



Why is Georgia So Republican?

Congress Races Begin

More of the Blame Game

Second Scandal of the Run-Off

First Scandal of the Run-Off

The Blogosphere Reacts

Lessons Learned: How 'Bout Dem Bloggers?

Lessons Learned: Democrats Want a Shot

Lessons Learned: Not-Reed and the Regulars

In-Vote Entertainment: Immigration

In-Vote Entertainment: The Environment

In-Vote Entertainment: The Economy

Konop Keeps Hope Alive

Erickson Goes After Stebin Horne

Georgia Gets an Orlando Jones Sighting

Cox Will Go Down Swinging

ZDNet Open Source

Government Support for Open Source Wireless Mesh

Desktop Margin Compression, Helped by Open Source

VMWare Cries Foul on XenSource-Microsoft Deal

No One Said Intellectual Property Was Dead

What Does Microsoft's Xen Relationship Mean?

McAfee Admits Proprietary Process Failure


Clued-in, Clueless

Clued-in is William Hurley. Now if you've got a blog, Bill, blog.

Clueless is Israel. l You can't kill 'em all.

A-Clue.Com is a free email publication, registered with the U.S. Copyright Office as number TXu 888-819. We're on the Web at

Home | Dana's Bio | Clued-In Archive | Newsletter '02 Archive | | Subscribe!